7 Red Flags Your “Vintage” Jewelry Might Be Fake

Vintage reproductions are flooding markets. Here’s how to spot them:

1. 1. Hallmarks That Don’t Add Up

      Genuine vintage pieces have specific hallmarks based on their era:

      • 1920s-1930s: Look for “925” (sterling) or “14K” stamps in cursive fonts.
      • 1950s: Many US pieces lack purity marks due to postwar material shortages.
      • Red Flag: Modern “©” or “™” symbols (introduced in 1980s).

   2. Too Perfect Symmetry

      Handmade vintage items show slight irregularities. Use a ruler:

      • Art Deco (1920s): Geometric but not laser-precise.
      • Victorian: Floral engravings with visible tool marks.

Where to Buy Authentic Vintage Jewelry in the USA

Trusted spots based on dealer interviews:

1. Estate Sales

• Pro Tip: Arrive early for best picks but stay late for discounts.
• Ask For: Original receipts or family photos showing the piece worn.

2. Auction Houses

• Best for: High-value Art Nouveau or signed pieces (e.g., Cartier, Van Cleef).
• Warning: Buyer premiums add 15-25% to final cost.

Negotiation Secrets From Antique Dealers

“Never say ‘I love it’—dealers can smell desperation. Instead, ask ‘What’s the best price for cash?’”

5 Phrases That Get Discounts

• • “I notice this clasp is loose…” (Point out flaws politely)
  • “Would you consider $X if I buy multiple pieces?”

Caring for Vintage Jewelry

Mistakes that destroy value:

• Never Use: Ultrasonic cleaners on porous stones (opal, pearl).
• Storage Tip: Wrap in acid-free tissue, never plastic.

Vintage Jewelry FAQs

Want to Learn More?

Grab our Free Vintage Jewelry Checklist covering:

• Hallmark timelines by decade
• Questions to ask sellers
• Must-have authentication tools

Download Now →